In our Department, as at many, one of the principal options for fulfilling the PhD “dissertation” requirement is the preparation of three “publishable” (if not published) manuscripts for journals in the discipline, although the option to do a monograph format (“traditional”) thesis still exists Last week, Chris made the argument for the Thesis by Publication route. Today, I want to talk about why I decided to do a monograph. My PhD continued the research from my Masters degree. The research I had done in my Masters of Research degree was the beginning of a big blogger.comted Reading Time: 3 mins A PhD thesis is a sophisticated test of research abilities and is aimed at an audience of your supervisor, examiners and immediate colleagues. A monograph is aimed at a broader audience of academics and researchers and the approach should change blogger.comted Reading Time: 12 mins
Article-based PhD thesis or a monograph? – ECHER
Getting all sorts of confusing advice, and not knowing how to move on? Let us help you out of the dilemma! There are two main types of dissertations. One is the monograph, and the other is the paper-based dissertation:, phd thesis monograph.
But, with the growing importance of academic papers peer-reviewed articles and the simultaneous declining importance of scholarly works published as a book monograph in many disciplines, this has shifted.
The paper-based dissertation is more common in the natural sciences, life sciences, medical sciences, engineering and quantitative social phd thesis monograph than in the humanities. So one determining factor is the research area in which you work. Also, phd thesis monograph, different countries still have different preferences, or are about to shift from monograph to paper-based dissertations.
Often, PhD students opt for a paper-based phd thesis monograph at the beginning of their PhD studies, but that may change during the PhD process. The university from which you graduate, phd thesis monograph more specifically your faculty decides. Even within your faculty, your specific discipline can hammer out particular requirements for submitting the dissertation, phd thesis monograph.
In some countries this is also subject to ministerial orders, governmental acts, and rulings, phd thesis monograph. The university regulations are the framework within which you operate.
It looks impressive on the book shelf in your office or in the library. You have a lot of freedom in the way you write, deciding rather freely on the layout, and how to include photographs, tables, figures or data-sheets. That means you have more freedom with the timeline in which you write your dissertation — it is you who makes the decisions, phd thesis monograph.
What is often considered problematic about the monograph in the natural sciences and life sciences, is that most scholars find it too much to read in comparison to papers. Ask yourself: How many monographic PhD dissertations have you read cover to cover? Hmm, phd thesis monograph, zero?
If you do not plan to publish your monograph as a book with a publisher, it will have a relatively low distribution, with only a few copies going to the university library. International accessibility is then a real issue. Accessibility is further restricted if you write in a language other than English. Clearly, if you consider the individual papers, the paper-based dissertation presents less to read than a monograph. Through the publishing platforms or the open access platforms and indexing databases, your peer-reviewed papers are far more widely distributed and accessible.
Also, phd thesis monograph, the external peer-review process is often considered as a quality-label regarding your scholarly work. In addition, you start your academic career already having some papers to your name, whereas with the monograph you might need to write additional papers!
You single out the very best and most innovative bits to write about. For the paper-based dissertation you are heavily dependant on decisions and deadlines of journals and editors.
Plus, phd thesis monograph is a risk of one or more of your papers being rejected. And that can make the entire process rather tricky. The process for a paper-based dissertation is not entirely in your hands. It needs very careful planning and decision-making early on in order to avoid trouble. We so much want you to have a smooth PhD process, and the best way to do this is to be really clear about the exact requirements of your dissertation!
You can make your PhD process a lot easier, if you know early on, which option might be best in your case and what the specific consequences of your choice are, phd thesis monograph. Let us help you on the way! We hope we could shed some light on the important matter phd thesis monograph submitting a paper-based PhD dissertation or a monograph, phd thesis monograph. We would love to hear from your experiences on this topic!
Did you have a good or not-so-good experience with the paper-based dissertation? What is most common in your discipline? And for all of you who completed already: What would you advise other PhD students to consider?
Do you want to complete your PhD successfully? If so, please sign up to receive our free guides. Skip to primary navigation Skip to main content Skip to footer Blog 6: Dissertation dilemma? Hand in a monograph or papers? Click here to register for the free webinar Are you pondering one of the following issues: Not exactly sure what the differences are between a monograph or a paper-based dissertation?
Not quite sure what the university requirements are? What you need to be aware of in order to have a smooth process? The two main types of PhD dissertations There are two main types of dissertations. One is the monograph, and the other is the paper-based dissertation: 1 The monograph is what one always wrote in order to get the PhD degree, phd thesis monograph.
Which type is more common? Who decides what can be handed in? Monograph — key features What you submit: A research-report with a comprehensive record of pretty much the total research you did during your PhD time. It can include all findings of your study right from the start until the end. Authorship: You are the only author. Language: The monograph might be written in the national language.
You may have an option to choose between your national language s or English. Lengths: It varies. No kidding, this was a human geographer who graduated after 12 years and today is a professor at a phd thesis monograph in the Netherlands.
Most monographs would be in the range of to pages. Are you phd thesis monograph in a heavy weight monograph? Facebook Instagram.
Submitting my PhD Thesis
, time: 22:12Thesis types - Collection of articles and monograph - PhD - Wiki - blogger.com
Last week, Chris made the argument for the Thesis by Publication route. Today, I want to talk about why I decided to do a monograph. My PhD continued the research from my Masters degree. The research I had done in my Masters of Research degree was the beginning of a big blogger.comted Reading Time: 3 mins A doctoral thesis written as a monograph is structured in various chapters with an introduction and a conclusion, and the PhD-candidate is the sole author. Historically, a monograph was the preferred form of doctoral thesis, and it still is in some academic fields. Collection of articles # A PhD thesis is a sophisticated test of research abilities and is aimed at an audience of your supervisor, examiners and immediate colleagues. A monograph is aimed at a broader audience of academics and researchers and the approach should change blogger.comted Reading Time: 12 mins
No comments:
Post a Comment